Is the new Slovak government acting with impunity?

2023 12 06T141302Z 1 LYNXMPEJB50N0 RTROPTP 4 SLOVAKIA GOVERNMENT PROSECUTION scaled
FILE PHOTO: SMER-SSD party leader Robert Fico attends a press conference after the country's early parliamentary elections, in Bratislava, Slovakia, October 1, 2023. REUTERS/Radovan Stoklasa/File Photo

Slovakia’s new government, led by populist Prime Minister Robert Fico, approved an amendment of the country’s penal code to cancel the special prosecutor’s office that deals with most serious crimes and corruption. The move has been been criticized by President Zuzana Caputova, the opposition and non-governmental organisation who say it will harm the rule of law in the country.

The Arguments

The proposed alterations to the legislative process, aiming to transfer the prosecution of major crimes such as high-profile murders, terrorism, and corruption to regional prosecutors’ offices, which have not handled such cases for nearly two decades, are anticipated to be finalized in the coming weeks. The closure of the special prosecutors’ office is expected to be completed by mid-January.

Thousands of individuals gathered in the capital in the last days to express their opposition to the proposal, asserting that the proposed amendment poses a threat to the principles of the rule of law. The opposition, Progressive Slovakia, Christian Democrats, and Freedom and Solidarity parties, will organize more demonstrations in the following days.

According to the opposition, the amendments planned for the country’s penal code are perceived as an attempt to provide assistance to individuals suspected of corruption, particularly those associated with the leftist SMER (Direction), the party led by Prime Minister Robert Fico.

The Facts

Prime Minister Robert Fico, despite his party’s history ridden of corruption scandals, secured his fourth term in office after the party’s victory in Slovakia’s parliamentary election on September 30, advocating a pro-Russian and anti-American stance.

Critics express concerns that Fico’s return may prompt Slovakia to deviate from its pro-Western trajectory, drawing parallels with Hungary under Prime Minister Viktor Orban. Already, some elite investigators and police officials dealing with high-profile corruption cases have been terminated or placed on leave. The proposed legal changes also involve a reduction in penalties for corruption.

Under the previous government, which took office in 2020 with an anti-corruption agenda, numerous senior officials, police officers, judges, prosecutors, politicians, and businesspeople associated with Fico’s party faced charges and convictions for corruption and other offences. Fico promised to terminate the cases if he returned to power, saying the’re politically motivated. The fate of pending cases remains uncertain under the new legislation, but they will likely be ended.

The European Union announced that the impact of the reform will be debated with Commission and Council next week, as it is a “step backwards” regarding the rule of law.

More from Qonversations

TalkingPoint

Peace Summit in Switzerland

Swiss Summit: Can diplomacy end the war in Ukraine?

International

f5e8cd39 3dba 4931 a402 e44f9c763512

South African authorities turn to traditional healers in HIV fight

TalkingPoint

Wells Fargo

Are remote work monitoring tools fair or invasive?

TalkingPoint

China EV

EU Tariffs on Chinese EVs: Will they spark a trade war?

Front of mind